“But these sheep, what have they done?”
The full verse · 2 Samuel 24:17 · KJV
And unto the when he the that the , and , Lo, I have , and I have done : but these , what have they ? let thine , I pray thee, be against me, and against my .
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionDavid asks this question to spotlight the innocence of his people and shift divine judgment onto himself as their shepherd-king, using the interrogative form to amplify the injustice of punishing the sheep for the shepherd’s sin and to move God’s heart toward mercy.
The Response
What Scripture recordsGod responded through the angel of the Lord by commanding the angel to withhold his hand and stop the plague at the threshing floor of Araunah (2 Samuel 24:16). God then instructed David through the prophet Gad to build an altar at that location, where David offered sacrifices that turned away the divine wrath (2 Samuel 24:18-25).
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyDavid’s question cuts to the heart of covenant responsibility: why should the innocent bear the guilty one’s judgment? The Hebrew construction places ‘I’ (ani) in emphatic position, ‘I have sinned, I have done wickedly’, before contrasting it with ‘these sheep’ (hatson ha’eleh), highlighting the shepherd-flock relationship. By framing his confession as a question rather than mere statement, David forces the issue: divine justice demands an answer when punishment falls on the wrong party. Keil and Delitzsch note that David ‘not only confesses his sin, but offers himself as a sacrifice for his people.’ The question form intensifies the intercession, appealing to God’s righteousness while acknowledging that David alone deserved the plague. This moment reveals the shepherd-king’s highest calling: to stand between God’s wrath and the people, prefiguring the ultimate Shepherd who would absorb judgment completely.
When your failure harms those you lead, take full ownership without deflecting blame. David didn’t minimize his census or rationalize it, he stood between his people and judgment, asking God to redirect consequences onto himself. This models Christlike leadership that protects rather than abandons when things go wrong. When you’ve sinned and others suffer the fallout, intercede boldly for them while acknowledging your fault. Confess specifically: ‘I did this; let the cost fall on me.’ Then take concrete steps toward restoration, just as David built an altar and made sacrifice. Romans 12:18 calls us to live at peace with everyone ‘if possible, as far as it depends on you,’ which sometimes means absorbing consequences you’ve caused. Leadership isn’t about perfection, it’s about standing in the gap when you’ve created the gap.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources
Keep questioning
“What one nation in the earth is like thy people, even like Israel, whom God went to redeem for a people to himself, and to make him a name, and to do for you great things and terrible, for thy land, before thy people, which thou redeemedst to thee from Egypt, from the nations and their gods?”
“Who am I, O Lord GOD?”
“How shall the ark of the LORD come to me?”
“Shall I go up against the Philistines?”