“Shall he prosper?”
The full verse · Ezekiel 17:15 · KJV
But he against him in his into , that they might him and . Shall he ? shall he that such things? or shall he the , and be ?
Asked by
Asked to
The question addresses the exiled community in Babylon concerning King Zedekiah’s covenant violation, forcing communal acknowledgment of divine justice.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionGod climaxes the interrogative sequence by explicitly naming covenant-breaking (berith), forcing Israel to choose between defending Zedekiah’s treachery or affirming God’s justice in judgment, eliminating all ambiguity about the theological issue at stake.
The Response
What Scripture recordsGod responds with emphatic oath in verses 16-19, swearing by His own life that Zedekiah will die in Babylon, explicitly stating ‘he despised the oath by breaking the covenant’ and therefore cannot escape divine judgment.
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyThe third question drives to the theological core by explicitly naming covenant violation. The Hebrew verb parar (break) means to frustrate, annul, make void, not accidental breach but deliberate nullification. God frames covenant-breaking and escaping judgment as logical contraries that cannot coexist. The conjunction “and yet” forces recognition that covenant structure itself, not mere divine preference, makes escape impossible. By questioning rather than declaring, God invites Israel to internalize covenant logic before experiencing its consequences. This carries profound theological weight: Yahweh’s governance operates through covenant framework so fundamental that escape from broken covenant equals escape from reality itself, an ontological impossibility rather than merely a practical difficulty.
Integrity isn’t optional when convenient. God’s final question exposes the fantasy that we can enjoy covenant blessings while abandoning covenant commitments. Like Zedekiah invoking God’s name in his oath to Nebuchadnezzar then seeking Egyptian rescue, we claim God’s protection while violating promises made in His name. Marriage vows, business integrity, church commitments; we wonder why blessings evaporate when we treat binding covenants as negotiable contracts. The question demands an answer: Can faithlessness and favor coexist? The gospel provides what Zedekiah lacked: Christ’s covenant-keeping covers our covenant-breaking, but relationship with Him transforms us into people who keep our word because He keeps His (2 Corinthians 1:20, 1 John 2:6).
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources