“Who commanded you to build this house, and to make up these walls?”
The full verse · Ezra 5:9 · KJV
we , and unto them , you to , and to make ?
Asked by
Asked to
The elders or leaders of the Jewish community who were overseeing the temple reconstruction, specifically those who could provide official documentation and historical justification for the building project.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionTattenai exercises his governmental authority to determine whether the Jews possess legitimate imperial authorization for their building project. By asking rather than immediately ordering a halt, he follows proper Persian administrative protocol that requires investigating claims before taking enforcement action. The question puts the burden on the Jews to produce documentation proving their legal right to build.
The Response
What Scripture recordsThe Jewish elders responded by recounting their history: how Nebuchadnezzar had destroyed Solomon’s temple because of their fathers’ sins, how Cyrus had decreed the temple’s rebuilding in his first year, and how Sheshbazzar had laid its foundation (Ezra 5:11-16). They requested that Darius search the royal archives in Babylon to verify Cyrus’s decree, demonstrating confidence in the legitimacy of their authorization.
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyTattenai’s question probes the legal foundation of the Jewish temple project, asking who granted the authorization to build this specific structure. The Aramaic term ta’am carries legal weight, referring to an official imperial decree rather than mere permission. The question functions as a formal administrative inquiry, not hostile opposition. Tattenai investigates rather than immediately condemning. The interrogative form reflects Persian bureaucratic process: governors must document their actions and verify claims before enforcing policy. This question carries theological weight because it forces the Jews to articulate that their ultimate authorization comes from the God of heaven working through earthly kings. The question becomes pivotal because it leads to Darius searching the archives, discovering Cyrus’s decree, and issuing even stronger support for the temple project. What began as administrative scrutiny became divine providence advancing God’s purposes.
Every believer faces moments when our spiritual work is questioned by those who demand our credentials. The Jewish elders didn’t retreat or grow defensive; they pointed to a higher authority than themselves and invited verification. When your obedience to God is challenged, rest in the confidence that God Himself has authorized your calling. Like these builders, keep documentation of what God has done and said, whether through His Word, spiritual milestones, or confirmed callings. Remember that legitimate spiritual authority always welcomes scrutiny because it rests on God’s proven faithfulness, not on human approval. The elders’ calm response came from knowing they had acted rightly. Let your confidence come from the same source, trusting that God will vindicate His own work in His time (1 Peter 2:12).
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources
Keep questioning
“Who hath commanded you to build this house, and to make up this wall?”
“What are the names of the men that make this building?”
“Now, O our God, what shall we say after this?”
“Should we again break thy commandments, and join in affinity with the people of these abominations?”