“And how saidst thou, She is my sister?”
The full verse · Genesis 26:9 · KJV
And , and , Behold, of a she is thy : and thou, She is my ? And unto him, Because I , I for her.
Asked by
Asked to
Isaac, son of Abraham and patriarch of the covenant line, who had just been caught in his deception about his wife.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionAbimelech confronts Isaac’s deception by forcing him to acknowledge the lie publicly and explain his reasoning. The king exposes the danger Isaac’s falsehood created for the entire Philistine community, establishing moral authority over the covenant bearer who should have trusted God’s protection.
The Response
What Scripture recordsIsaac admitted his deception immediately, explaining, ‘Because I thought, Lest I die because of her.’ He offered no elaborate justification, only the bare confession that fear for his life motivated the lie. Abimelech accepted this explanation without further confrontation but issued a protective decree forbidding anyone to harm Isaac or Rebekah.
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyAbimelech’s question cuts to the heart of Isaac’s failure by juxtaposing reality with deception. The emphatic ‘Behold’ (hinneh) forces Isaac to see what he tried to hide, the undeniable truth that Rebekah is his wife. By asking ‘how then’ rather than simply condemning, Abimelech invites explanation while exposing the irrationality of the lie. The Hebrew construction emphasizes the contradiction: knowing she is your wife, how could you say otherwise? The king frames this as a question rather than a direct accusation to allow Isaac dignity in confession while still establishing the moral high ground. This confrontation carries theological weight because the pagan king upholds truth and protects the covenant family, while the heir of Abraham compromises both through fearful deception.
Fear makes liars of us all when we forget whose we are. Isaac’s deception reveals how quickly we compromise truth when we stop trusting God’s protection and start managing our own safety. The patriarch who should have been a testimony to God’s faithfulness instead required a pagan king’s rebuke. When you’re tempted to shade the truth to avoid consequences, remember that Christ has already secured your ultimate safety (Romans 8:31-39). The temporary danger you fear cannot separate you from God’s love or derail His purposes. Trust Him enough to tell the truth, even when honesty feels dangerous. Your integrity glorifies God more than your survival strategies ever could.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources
Keep questioning
“What is this thou hast done unto us?”
“Who is this woman?”
“Come ye to me, seeing ye hate me, and have sent me away from you?”
“What mean these seven ewe lambs which thou hast set by themselves?”