“Why then should I think upon a maid?”
The full verse · Job 31:1 · KJV
I a with mine ; why then should I upon a ?
Asked by
Asked to
Primarily Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar, though the broader scope includes any who might accuse Job of hidden sin.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionJob employs this rhetorical question to demonstrate the logical impossibility of lustful gazing given his prior commitment. The interrogative form creates cognitive dissonance, forcing his accusers to acknowledge that covenant faithfulness necessarily excludes the very sins they insinuate.
The Response
What Scripture recordsNo verbal response is recorded from Job’s friends at this point in the discourse. Job continues his oath of innocence through chapter 31, cataloging various sins he has avoided. The friends remain silent until God speaks from the whirlwind in chapter 38.
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyJob’s question reveals the internal logic of covenant commitment. Having established a binding agreement with his eyes, he presents the rhetorical impossibility of then gazing lustfully at a virgin. The Hebrew verb histakel (to gaze) intensifies beyond casual seeing to intentional, contemplative looking. Job is not claiming never to have seen unmarried women but rather that covenant faithfulness categorically excludes the deliberate, desirous stare. He frames this as a question rather than a simple declaration to invite his accusers into his moral reasoning, challenging them to identify any flaw in his ethical framework. The weight of this self-examination establishes Job’s credibility throughout chapter 31, as he systematically addresses potential areas of hidden sin. His covenant with his eyes becomes the foundation for claims of sexual purity, demonstrating that righteousness begins with governing one’s internal appetites, not merely avoiding external acts.
Your eyes are either covenant-keepers or covenant-breakers. Job understood that purity is won or lost at the point of first gaze, not at the moment of physical contact. In a culture saturated with visual temptation, his ancient wisdom speaks powerfully: make your commitment before the temptation arrives. This means establishing boundaries for what you watch, where you look, and how you scroll before your eyes wander toward compromise. As 1 John 2:16 warns against the lust of the eyes, we must recognize that what we feed through our gaze shapes what we crave in our hearts. The covenant Job made was not legalistic restraint but protective love, guarding both his own integrity and the dignity of women around him. By God’s grace, you can make the same covenant today, asking the Holy Spirit to alert you when your eyes begin to stray and to redirect your gaze toward what is pure, lovely, and worthy of praise.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources
Keep questioning
“Who knoweth not in all these that the hand of the LORD hath wrought this?”
“Yea, who knoweth not such things as these?”
“Is my strength the strength of stones?”
“Whence then cometh wisdom?”