Back to database
2197 / 2430
New TestamentRomans 3:5Pauline Epistles
“But if our unrighteousness commend the righteousness of God, what shall we say? Is God unrighteous who taketh vengeance?”

The full verse · Romans 3:5 · KJV

the of , shall we ? Is who ? (I a )

Asked by

Paul

Paul: the apostle to the Gentiles, voicing an objection to his own teaching so he can answer it (Romans 1:1; 3:5)

Asked to

Romans

Romans: the believers in Rome, called to be saints (Romans 1:7), here following Paul's argument about the Jew's advantage (Romans 3:1-2)

The Scene

Paul has just declared, "let God be true, but every man a liar," quoting David's confession that God is justified when He judges (Romans 3:4; Psalm 51:4).

Why It Was Asked

Paul had just said that human falsehood makes God's truth stand out. Someone could twist that: if my sin makes God look good, how can He punish me for it? Paul states the objection himself. Barnes explains that "commend" means to "show forth" or "render illustrious." The first question asks what follows from that idea. The second states the bold conclusion an objector would draw: that God would be unrighteous to punish. Paul adds "(I speak as a man)" to show this is not his own view. Gill says the apostle "did not speak the sentiments of his own mind, he represented another man, and spoke in the language of an adversary."

The Response

Paul rejects the idea at once: "God forbid: for then how shall God judge the world?" (Romans 3:6). If God could not justly punish sin, He could not judge anyone. Paul then shows where the objection leads, to "Let us do evil, that good may come," and says of those who argue that way, "whose damnation is just" (Romans 3:7-8).

Historical Context

"I speak as a man" was a way of saying, "I am putting this the way people reason." Barnes explains that the objector expressed a sentiment which "to human view would seem to follow." The KJV "taketh vengeance" is rendered by the ESV as "inflict wrath on us," pointing back to the "wrath of God" Paul described in Romans 1:18 and Romans 2:5.

Paul had just quoted Psalm 51:4, David's confession after his sin, owning that God is "clear when thou judgest."

The Bigger Picture

This question tests whether God's goodness can be used against Him. Barnes names the flaw in the objection: sin does not tend to glorify God. God gets glory by "reversing that tendency, or overruling it." God can bring good out of evil, but that does not make the evil good.

The question also guards God's right to judge. Paul has spent two chapters showing that God will render "to every man according to his deeds" (Romans 2:6). The objection would undo that, so Paul answers it with God's role as Judge of the world (Romans 3:6).

Look Closer

1 of 2

Why does Paul add "(I speak as a man)" in Romans 3:5?

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God
Lord, when I am tempted to excuse my sin because You can bring good out of it, what do You want me to see about Your justice?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others
  1. In what ways do people today argue that their wrongs are not really their fault?
  2. Paul answered a hard question about God by holding on to what he knew was true about God. How do you handle questions about God that you cannot fully answer yet?

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

For Your Life Today

God's grace is real, and He can bring good out of the worst things. But that never turns sin into a gift to God. If you catch yourself thinking, "It worked out, so it wasn't really wrong," remember Paul's answer: God still judges the world (Romans 3:6).

Paul did not ignore this hard objection. He named it and answered it from what is true of God: He is righteous, and He judges the world (Romans 3:6). When hard questions about God come up, that is a good place to start.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources