“Lord, wherefore hast thou so evil entreated this people?”
The full verse · Exodus 5:22 · KJV
And unto the , and , , wherefore hast thou so evil this ? why is it that thou hast me?
Asked by
Asked to
Moses addresses God directly in private prayer, not a public assembly, following his failed confrontation with Pharaoh.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionMoses voices raw bewilderment and complaint to shift the burden of Israel’s worsening oppression back onto God, whose commission has seemingly backfired. By framing his protest as questions rather than accusations, Moses maintains covenant relationship while demanding divine accountability for outcomes he cannot reconcile with God’s promises.
The Response
What Scripture recordsGod does not directly answer Moses’ questions but instead reaffirms His covenant faithfulness and promises imminent deliverance in Exodus 6:1-8. The Lord declares His name, recalls His covenant with the patriarchs, acknowledges Israel’s groaning, and pledges five acts of redemption: ‘I will bring you out… I will deliver you… I will redeem you… I will take you as my people… I will bring you into the land.’
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyMoses’ twin questions expose the chasm between divine commission and earthly outcome. His first question uses the stark Hebrew ra’a, asking why God has ‘done evil’ to His own people, a bold term that captures Moses’ shock at the apparent contradiction between covenant promise and present calamity. The second question pivots inward, challenging the very legitimacy of Moses’ own calling: if this mission was divinely ordained, why has it produced only disaster? Moses asks rather than accuses because he still speaks within covenant relationship, not outside it. The interrogative form preserves dialogue even in despair. Theologically, this passage affirms that God permits His servants to voice confusion and protest without being rejected, establishing a biblical pattern of honest lament that runs through Job, the Psalms, Jeremiah, and Habakkuk.
When obedience to God makes things worse before they get better, honest lament is not rebellion. Moses teaches us that faith can hold both trust in God’s character and bewilderment at His methods in the same prayer. Like Moses, we can bring our ‘why’ questions directly to God rather than nursing them into bitterness or theological pretense. Romans 8:28 promises that God works all things for good, but it doesn’t promise immediate explanation. The space between promise and fulfillment is where raw prayer keeps us tethered to the One who sees what we cannot yet see, and who often works most powerfully through the very obedience that seems to fail.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources