Back to database
851 / 2430
Old TestamentJob 9:29Wisdom & Poetry
“If I be wicked, why then labour I in vain?”

The full verse · Job 9:29 · KJV

If I be , why then I in ?

Asked by

Job

Asked to

God

Job directs this to God, though speaking within his broader defense before his three friends (Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar).

Why It Was Asked

Job questions the value of striving for righteousness when he perceives his condemnation as inevitable, exposing the despair that accompanies feeling abandoned by divine justice. By framing his resignation as a question rather than declaration, he invites God to answer the problem of suffering that afflicts the innocent.

The Response

God does not respond immediately in this chapter. Job continues his lament through chapter 31, and God eventually answers Job from the whirlwind in chapters 38-41, addressing Job’s questions about divine justice and sovereignty without directly explaining Job’s suffering.

The Bigger Picture

Job’s question expresses profound theological crisis. Having argued that he cannot win against God’s power (verses 2-24), he now concludes that striving for innocence is pointless. The Hebrew word ‘amal, translated labor, carries connotations of toilsome effort, often used for humanity’s cursed work after Eden. Why pose this as a question rather than simple resignation? Because Job refuses merely to accept absurdity; he demands that God account for the apparent meaninglessness of righteous effort under divine condemnation. This question cuts to the heart of the book’s central tension: does moral effort matter when suffering comes regardless? Job’s interrogative form preserves the dialogical nature of faith, refusing both easy answers and silent despair.

For Your Life Today

When your best efforts seem to lead nowhere and condemnation feels inevitable, you’ve touched Job’s darkness. Recognize that even faithful labor can feel futile when suffering clouds your vision of God’s purposes. Yet Christ’s finished work means your labor in Him is never vain, 1 Corinthians 15:58 promises that your work in the Lord always has value, even when circumstances scream otherwise. Bring your raw questions to God as Job did, trusting that resurrection answers what present darkness cannot explain.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources