Back to database
1775 / 2430
New TestamentMark 9:19Gospels
“How long shall I be with you? How long shall I suffer you?”

The full verse · Mark 9:19 · KJV

He , , , how shall I ? how shall I ? .

Asked by

Jesus

Jesus: the Son of God and promised Messiah, who had just come down from the mountain to find His disciples unable to help a suffering boy (Mark 9:14-18)

Asked to

Boy's Father, Scribes, Disciples, Crowd

Boy's Father: the man from the multitude who had brought his son with a dumb spirit to the disciples (Mark 9:17-18); Scribes: the experts in the law who had been questioning with the disciples (Mark 9:14); Disciples: "his disciples" (Mark 9:14), the followers of Jesus whom He found with "a great multitude about them" when He came down from the mountain (Mark 9:9, 14); the father had asked them to cast the spirit out of his son, "and they could not" (Mark 9:18); Crowd: the great multitude gathered around them (Mark 9:14-15)

The Scene

A father from the crowd tells Jesus that his son has a dumb spirit that throws him down, and that the disciples tried to cast it out, "and they could not" (Mark 9:17-18).

Why It Was Asked

Jesus spoke into the unbelief all around Him. These two questions are not asking for information. They are a lament over how long He must stay with, and bear with, people who will not believe.

The commentators differ on whom He meant. Gill says Jesus answered the father, "who is included in the reproof afterwards given, for his unbelief, and taking part with the Scribes against his disciples." Where some ancient versions read "them," Gill takes it to mean "not his disciples, but the Scribes and Pharisees, with the father of the child." Writing on the parallel in Matthew 17:17, Barnes says "Jesus applied this, probably, to the Jews, and not to his real disciples," and calls it "not so much an expression of impatience or complaint as a reproof for their being so slow to believe that he was the Messiah." Yet it was the disciples' failure that brought the case to Jesus (Mark 9:18), and in Matthew He tells them they failed "Because of your unbelief" (Matthew 17:20). So the disciples' own faith was also at issue.

The Response

Jesus follows His questions with a command: "bring him unto me." They brought the boy, and at once the spirit "tare him; and he fell on the ground, and wallowed foaming" (Mark 9:20). Jesus asked the father how long this had been, heard his plea, "if thou canst do any thing," and answered, "If thou canst believe, all things are possible to him that believeth" (Mark 9:21-23). The father cried, "Lord, I believe; help thou mine unbelief" (Mark 9:24). Jesus rebuked the spirit, took the boy by the hand, "and he arose" (Mark 9:25-27).

Historical Context

"Faithless" is apistos, meaning unbelieving. "Generation" (genea) points beyond one person to the people of that time. "Suffer" is anechomai, to bear with or have patience with. That is why the ESV reads, "How long am I to bear with you?" Barnes explains it: "how long shall I bear with you? How long is it necessary to show such patience and forbearance with your unbelief and perversity?"

The Greek texts differ slightly here. The Textus Receptus, followed by the KJV, says Jesus "answereth him" (the father). Other editions read "them," as the ESV does. Gill notes that several ancient translations also read "them."

The Bigger Picture

These questions show how Jesus regards unbelief. He did not pretend it was nothing. Yet in the same breath He said, "bring him unto me." The rebuke and the invitation come together. His patience was being tested, but it did not run out.

The rest of the story shows where that patience leads. The father, hearing Jesus speak of belief, does not claim a perfect faith. He cries, "Lord, I believe; help thou mine unbelief" (Mark 9:24), and Jesus heals his son. The One who lamented faithlessness is the same One who answers weak faith with power.

Look Closer

1 of 3

What had just happened before Jesus asked these questions?

Your Turn to Ask

Carry the question into prayer and conversation.

Ask God
Lord Jesus, You grieved over unbelief and still said, "bring him unto me"; what am I holding back from bringing to You?

A prayer to carry into the day.

Ask Yourself and Others
  1. What do these questions show you about how Jesus feels about unbelief, and about the people who struggle with it?
  2. Tell about a time when your faith felt weak, but you brought your need to Jesus anyway.

For you, a small group, a friend, or the dinner table.

For Your Life Today

Jesus takes unbelief seriously, and He said so. But His very next words were, "bring him unto me." When faith runs thin, the answer is not to stay away from Him until you feel stronger. It is to bring what you have, and who you love, to Him.

The failure of the disciples did not stop Jesus from helping. If other believers have let you down, or you have let others down, the need can still be brought to Him.

This doesn't mean unbelief doesn't matter. The rebuke is real. But the father's prayer, "Lord, I believe; help thou mine unbelief" (Mark 9:24), shows that honest, imperfect faith is welcome.

Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources