“Wilt thou be angry with us for ever?”
The full verse · Psalm 85:5 · KJV
Wilt thou be with us for ? wilt thou draw thine to ?
Asked by
Asked to
The question is directed to Yahweh on behalf of the covenant community of Israel, particularly in a context of national distress or divine discipline.
Why It Was Asked
The purpose behind the questionThe psalmist uses questions rather than statements to invite God into dialogue about His apparent displeasure, transforming despair into petition. By framing divine anger as a question, the worshiper acknowledges God’s sovereignty while creating space for hope that His wrath has limits. The interrogative form expresses both genuine anguish and implicit faith that God’s character includes mercy.
The Response
What Scripture recordsThe psalm itself transitions from lament to confidence without recording a direct divine answer. Instead, the psalmist moves to petition for revival (verse 6) and expresses assurance that God will speak peace to His people (verse 8). The questions remain unanswered in explicit terms but are met with liturgical confidence in God’s steadfast love and faithfulness (verses 7, 10-13).
The Bigger Picture
Where this fits in God's storyThe dual questions form a Hebrew parallelism intensifying a single concern: whether God’s discipline has become permanent. The psalmist uses the imperfect tense in Hebrew, which can convey both present reality and future possibility, ‘Are you angry?’ and ‘Will you continue to be angry?’ The choice to question rather than assert (‘You are angry with us forever!’) preserves the covenant relationship by assuming God is open to persuasion and bound by His own character. The phrase ‘draw out’ (Hebrew mashak) suggests the deliberate extension of something, as one draws out a thread or prolongs a conversation. This reveals the psalmist’s concern that what should be temporary correction might become perpetual rejection. The theological weight rests on Israel’s understanding that God’s covenant loyalty (chesed) must ultimately triumph over His necessary wrath, making the question both urgent and hope-filled.
When God’s silence feels like anger, your questions are not rebellion but relationship. The Sons of Korah didn’t hide their fear that divine displeasure might be permanent; they brought that terror directly to God in worship. You can do the same when circumstances suggest God has turned away, when prayers seem to bounce off the ceiling, when consequences of sin linger, when suffering persists across years. Ask Him plainly: ‘How long will this last?’ Your honest questions honor Him more than false serenity. The psalmists teach us that lament belongs in the sanctuary, that corporate worship can hold our rawest doubts. Like them, ground your questions in God’s past faithfulness (‘You were favorable to your land,’ verse 1) and end with confidence in His character, even before circumstances change. Romans 8:1 assures you that in Christ, God’s anger toward you has an expiration date, it ended at the cross.
Built from the biblical text and checked against trusted commentaries and lexicons. References & Sources